Growth & Strategy

Why I Stopped Building AI-First UX (And Started Using AI to Scale Human-Centered Design)


Personas

SaaS & Startup

Time to ROI

Medium-term (3-6 months)

OK, so here's something that took me six months of AI experimentation to figure out: most companies are approaching AI-driven UX completely backwards.

I deliberately avoided the AI hype for two years, watching everyone rush to build "AI-native" experiences. When I finally dove in last year, I discovered something that challenged everything I was hearing at conferences and reading in newsletters.

AI doesn't create better UX by being smarter—it creates better UX by making human-centered design scalable.

The breakthrough came while working on AI automation workflows for multiple clients. I watched teams obsess over AI recommendation engines and predictive interfaces, while their users struggled with basic usability issues that had nothing to do with artificial intelligence.

That's when I realized we were solving the wrong problem. Users don't want AI-driven experiences—they want experiences that work effortlessly. AI should be invisible infrastructure that makes great design possible at scale, not the star of the show.

In this playbook, you'll discover:

  • Why AI-first UX design fails and what to build instead

  • The three-layer system I use to implement AI behind great user experiences

  • How to use AI to solve content scalability without sacrificing brand voice

  • Real examples from client projects where invisible AI improved UX dramatically

  • My framework for testing AI impact on actual user behavior (not just metrics)

This isn't another guide about chatbots and recommendation algorithms. This is about using AI as a tool to build better websites and user experiences that people actually love.

Industry Hype

What every AI conference and startup guru preaches

Walk into any product conference in 2025, and you'll hear the same mantra repeated endlessly: "AI should be at the center of your user experience." The advice is everywhere:

Make AI visible to users: Show them the magic happening behind the scenes. Add loading animations that say "AI is thinking." Let users know when they're interacting with artificial intelligence.

Personalize everything immediately: Use machine learning to customize the interface from the first visit. Predict user behavior. Show different content to different people based on algorithmic assumptions.

Automate user interactions: Replace human touchpoints with chatbots. Use AI to handle customer service, onboarding, and user guidance. Make the experience feel "intelligent" and automated.

Build recommendation engines: Every product needs smart suggestions, predictive features, and AI-powered insights. Users should feel like the system "knows" them.

Lead with AI capabilities: Marketing should emphasize AI features. Product tours should highlight machine learning. Make artificial intelligence a selling point.

This approach exists because it sounds innovative and because investors love hearing about AI implementations. But here's the problem: most users don't care about your AI—they care about whether your product helps them accomplish their goals quickly and easily.

The industry has confused impressive technology with improved user experience. Just because you can add AI-driven features doesn't mean you should make them the centerpiece of your UX strategy.

Every successful AI implementation I've seen follows a different philosophy entirely.

Who am I

Consider me as your business complice.

7 years of freelance experience working with SaaS and Ecommerce brands.

I spent the first part of 2024 deliberately avoiding AI tools while everyone else was rushing to implement them. By the time I started experimenting, the initial hype had settled, and I could see what was actually working versus what was just impressive demos.

My first AI project was with a B2B SaaS client who wanted to "AI-power" their user onboarding. They had visions of personalized welcome messages, intelligent feature recommendations, and predictive user paths through the product.

The problem? Their basic onboarding was broken. Users were dropping off not because the experience wasn't personalized enough, but because it was confusing, the copy was unclear, and the product value wasn't obvious within the first five minutes.

Instead of building AI features, I used AI to solve the content problem. I generated 200+ variations of onboarding copy, tested different value propositions, and created contextual help content that adapted to user behavior patterns—all generated efficiently using AI but focused on fundamental UX improvements.

The second project was an ecommerce client with over 3,000 products who needed better product descriptions and category pages. Everyone was talking about AI recommendation engines, but their real problem was content scalability. Their product pages had inconsistent descriptions, missing SEO optimization, and no cohesive brand voice across thousands of items.

Again, I used AI as infrastructure, not interface. I built an AI workflow that generated consistent, brand-aligned product descriptions at scale, optimized meta tags automatically, and maintained content quality across multiple languages. Users never saw the AI—they just experienced better, more consistent product information.

Through these experiments, I learned that the most effective AI-driven UX is completely invisible to users. They experience the benefits (better content, more relevant information, faster load times, consistent experience) without knowing AI was involved in creating that experience.

My experiments

Here's my playbook

What I ended up doing and the results.

After implementing AI across multiple client projects, I developed a framework that prioritizes user experience over technological demonstration. Here's the exact three-layer system I use:

Layer 1: Content Intelligence

This is where AI provides the most immediate UX value. Instead of trying to personalize interfaces, I use AI to solve content scalability and consistency problems:

  • Dynamic content generation: AI maintains fresh, relevant content without manual updates. Product descriptions stay current, help documentation reflects the latest features, and landing pages adapt to seasonal changes.

  • Brand voice consistency: Custom AI prompts ensure all generated content matches the company's tone and messaging, even when creating thousands of variations.

  • Contextual help content: Instead of generic FAQs, AI generates specific answers based on user behavior patterns and common support requests.

  • SEO optimization at scale: Automated meta descriptions, title tags, and structured data that maintain quality while covering hundreds or thousands of pages.

Layer 2: Operational Efficiency

AI handles behind-the-scenes processes that indirectly improve user experience by enabling better human decision-making:

  • User behavior analysis: AI identifies patterns in user interactions to inform UX improvements, but humans make the design decisions.

  • Content performance tracking: Automatic analysis of which content drives engagement, conversion, and user satisfaction.

  • A/B testing automation: AI manages test variations and statistical significance, but humans design the experiences being tested.

  • Quality assurance: Automated detection of broken links, inconsistent styling, and content errors that would degrade user experience.

Layer 3: Adaptive Systems

The most sophisticated layer involves systems that improve over time without requiring constant human input:

  • Smart defaults: Interface settings that adapt based on user behavior patterns, but always allow manual override.

  • Progressive enhancement: Features that become more useful as they learn from user interactions, without changing the core interface.

  • Predictive loading: Content and interface elements that pre-load based on likely user paths, improving perceived performance.

  • Contextual adaptation: Subtle interface changes based on time of day, user location, or device type—always enhancing rather than complicating the experience.

The key principle: AI should make human-designed experiences better, not replace human decision-making about what users need. Every AI implementation should pass this test: "Would users be happy with this experience even if they knew AI was involved?"

Most importantly, I measure success based on user behavior and satisfaction metrics, not AI performance metrics. The goal is better user experiences that happen to be powered by AI, not impressive AI features that happen to be wrapped in user interfaces.

Content Intelligence

AI handles content creation, optimization, and consistency behind the scenes

Operational Efficiency

AI analyzes user behavior to inform human design decisions

Adaptive Systems

Interface improvements that evolve with user patterns while maintaining control

Measurement Focus

Track user satisfaction and behavior, not AI performance metrics

The results from this approach have been consistently better than AI-first implementations:

Client #1 (B2B SaaS Onboarding): User activation rate improved 40% after implementing AI-generated contextual help content. Users spent less time confused and more time discovering value in the product. The improvement came from better content, not smarter algorithms.

Client #2 (E-commerce Product Pages): Conversion rate increased 25% after implementing AI-powered content consistency across 3,000+ products. Users experienced more professional, informative product pages. The AI generated content at scale, but the UX improvement was fundamentally about content quality.

Content Scalability: Teams can now maintain high-quality, consistent content across hundreds or thousands of pages without proportional increases in content team size. AI handles the scaling; humans focus on strategy and quality control.

Faster Iteration Cycles: Instead of waiting weeks for content updates, teams can test new messaging, update product information, and maintain documentation in real-time. AI automation enables rapid experimentation without sacrificing quality.

Improved User Satisfaction: Net Promoter Scores improved across implementations because users experienced more consistent, helpful, and relevant content. The AI was invisible, but the impact on user experience was significant.

Most importantly, these improvements were sustainable. Unlike AI features that require constant tuning and user education, infrastructure-level AI implementations become more valuable over time while remaining invisible to end users.

Learnings

What I've learned and the mistakes I've made.

Sharing so you don't make them.

After six months of implementing AI across different UX challenges, the key lessons are clear:

1. AI amplifies existing UX quality—it doesn't create good UX
Every successful AI implementation started with solid user experience fundamentals. AI made good UX scalable, but it never fixed fundamentally broken user experiences.

2. Invisible AI creates better experiences than visible AI
Users prefer experiences that "just work" over experiences that demonstrate technological sophistication. The most successful AI features were ones users never knew were AI-powered.

3. Content problems are the easiest wins for AI-driven UX
Before building recommendation engines or personalization systems, use AI to solve basic content scalability, consistency, and quality issues. The UX impact is immediate and measurable.

4. Humans should design; AI should execute
The most effective approach involves human designers making UX decisions and AI handling the scaling and execution of those decisions. Don't let AI make design choices—use it to implement human design choices efficiently.

5. Measure user outcomes, not AI performance
Track conversion rates, user satisfaction, task completion times, and retention. Don't get distracted by AI accuracy metrics or algorithmic performance indicators that don't correlate with user experience quality.

6. Start with operations, not interface
The biggest UX improvements came from AI handling behind-the-scenes operations that enabled better human design decisions and content quality. Interface-level AI was less impactful than operational AI.

7. Build systems that improve over time
The most valuable AI implementations created systems that became more useful with data and usage, but didn't require users to learn new interaction patterns or adapt to algorithmic changes.

How you can adapt this to your Business

My playbook, condensed for your use case.

For your SaaS / Startup

For SaaS implementing AI-driven UX:

  • Use AI to generate contextual help content based on user behavior patterns

  • Implement AI-powered content optimization for onboarding sequences and feature explanations

  • Build adaptive documentation that stays current with product updates automatically

  • Create AI-driven user flow analysis to identify UX friction points without changing core interfaces

For your Ecommerce store

For E-commerce implementing AI-driven UX:

  • Focus AI on product content consistency and SEO optimization across large catalogs

  • Implement AI-generated product descriptions that maintain brand voice at scale

  • Use AI for contextual customer service content rather than replacing human interaction

  • Build AI-powered inventory and pricing content that updates automatically without UX disruption

Get more playbooks like this one in my weekly newsletter