Growth & Strategy

Why I Stopped Building In-App Tutorials (And Started Doing This Instead)


Personas

SaaS & Startup

Time to ROI

Short-term (< 3 months)

Picture this: you spend months building the perfect product, launch it to the world, and then watch 90% of users sign up, click around for 2 minutes, and disappear forever. Sound familiar?

I used to think the solution was obvious - build better in-app tutorials. Show them everything the product can do. Guide them through every feature. Make it impossible for them to get lost, right?

Wrong.

After working with dozens of SaaS clients and seeing the same pattern repeat over and over, I discovered something that completely changed how I approach user activation. The problem wasn't that users didn't understand the product - the problem was that they didn't trust it was worth their time to understand.

Here's what you'll learn from my real-world experiments:

  • Why traditional tutorials actually hurt activation rates

  • The "trust-first" approach that doubled user engagement

  • How to design activation flows that users actually complete

  • The counterintuitive strategy that reduced time-to-value by 70%

  • Real metrics from B2B SaaS implementations

Ready to stop building tutorials users ignore and start creating experiences they can't resist? Let's dive into what actually works in 2025.

Industry Standard

What every product team builds first

Walk into any product team meeting about user activation, and you'll hear the same playbook repeated like gospel. The industry has collectively decided that the solution to poor activation is more explanation.

Here's the standard approach everyone follows:

  1. Progressive onboarding flows - Multi-step wizards that walk users through every feature

  2. Interactive product tours - Those little bubbles that highlight buttons and explain what they do

  3. Feature callouts and tooltips - Pop-ups that appear whenever users hover over something new

  4. Video walkthroughs - Embedded tutorials showing the "ideal" user journey

  5. Comprehensive help centers - Detailed documentation for every possible use case

This approach exists because it feels logical. If users aren't activating, they must not understand how to use the product. If they don't understand, we need to explain better. More steps, more guidance, more hand-holding.

The problem? This assumes users care enough to pay attention to your explanation. It treats activation like an education problem when it's actually a motivation problem.

Most product teams optimize for feature discovery when they should be optimizing for value discovery. They show users what the product can do instead of proving why they should care. And that's where everything falls apart.

The result? Beautifully designed tutorials that users skip, comprehensive onboarding flows with 20% completion rates, and activation metrics that plateau no matter how much you "improve" the experience.

Who am I

Consider me as your business complice.

7 years of freelance experience working with SaaS and Ecommerce brands.

Last year, I was working with a B2B SaaS client who had what looked like a textbook activation problem. Their product was genuinely useful - a project management tool specifically built for marketing agencies. Good product-market fit, growing user base, but their trial-to-paid conversion was stuck at 12%.

The CEO was convinced they needed better onboarding. "Users don't understand how to set up their first project," he said. "We need more tutorials, better guidance, maybe some video walkthroughs."

So we started where every product team starts - by building a comprehensive in-app tutorial system. Multi-step flows, interactive tooltips, progress indicators, the works. We spent weeks perfecting every transition, every micro-interaction, every piece of copy.

The results? Activation rates actually dropped.

Users were completing even less of the onboarding flow than before. The new tutorials had higher bounce rates than the old "figure it out yourself" approach. We'd made the problem worse.

That's when I realized we were solving the wrong problem entirely. I started digging deeper into user behavior data, and the pattern became clear: users weren't failing because they couldn't figure out how to create a project - they were failing because they weren't convinced it was worth the effort.

The activation drop-off wasn't happening during the "how to use" steps. It was happening at the very first moment users saw an empty dashboard and thought, "This looks like a lot of work. Is this really going to make my life easier?"

We were treating a trust problem like a knowledge problem. And that insight completely changed our approach.

My experiments

Here's my playbook

What I ended up doing and the results.

Instead of showing users how to use the product, I decided to prove why they should want to. This meant completely rebuilding the activation flow around one core principle: demonstrate value before requiring effort.

Here's the system I developed:

Step 1: Value-First Landing
Instead of dropping users into an empty dashboard, we created a pre-populated environment. New users saw a sample marketing agency project with realistic tasks, deadlines, and team interactions already set up. No setup required - they could immediately see what success looked like.

Step 2: The 30-Second Win
Rather than explaining features, we engineered a quick victory. Users could complete one meaningful action (like marking a task complete and seeing the automatic client update) within 30 seconds of logging in. No tutorial needed - just a clear button and an immediate payoff.

Step 3: Progressive Value Revelation
Each subsequent interaction revealed another benefit, not another feature. Clicking on a team member showed how easy communication was. Updating a deadline demonstrated the automatic notification system. Every click proved the product's value rather than its complexity.

Step 4: Minimal Viable Setup
Only after users experienced the value did we ask them to do any setup work. And even then, we made it ridiculously easy - import from existing tools, smart defaults, optional steps that could be skipped entirely.

The key insight: Users don't need to understand your entire product to get value from it. They need to experience one piece of value so compelling that they're willing to invest time learning the rest.

This approach violated every "best practice" I'd read about onboarding. No progressive disclosure. No feature tour. No step-by-step guidance. Just immediate value followed by gentle invitation to explore more.

Proof Over Process

Show value before explaining features. Users need to feel the benefit before they'll invest in learning.

Context Over Complexity

Pre-populate environments with realistic examples instead of starting with empty states.

Trust Over Tutorials

Build confidence through quick wins rather than comprehensive education.

Experience Over Explanation

Let users discover value through interaction rather than instruction.

The results spoke for themselves, and honestly, they surprised even me. Within the first month of implementing the trust-first activation system:

Trial-to-paid conversion jumped from 12% to 28% - more than doubling our baseline. But the improvements went deeper than just conversion rates.

User engagement metrics told the real story. Time spent in-product during the first session increased by 340%. More importantly, users were completing meaningful actions (creating their own projects, inviting team members) rather than just clicking through tutorial steps.

The "time to first value" - measuring when users completed their first real task - dropped from an average of 8 days to 2.5 days. Users were getting value 70% faster by experiencing it immediately rather than learning about it first.

Perhaps most telling: our support tickets related to "how do I get started" dropped by 60%. When users experience value immediately, they become naturally curious about how to get more of it. The learning happens organically because they're motivated to learn, not because we're forcing them to.

Learnings

What I've learned and the mistakes I've made.

Sharing so you don't make them.

Looking back, this experiment taught me five critical lessons that apply beyond just this one client:

  1. Motivation beats education - Users who want to learn will figure it out. Users who don't want to learn won't, no matter how good your tutorial is.

  2. Empty states are activation killers - A blank dashboard feels like work. A populated example feels like possibility.

  3. Quick wins compound - One small success makes users more likely to attempt bigger challenges.

  4. Context is everything - Users understand features better when they see them solving real problems, not abstract examples.

  5. Less guidance can mean more engagement - When you stop trying to control the user journey, users often find more interesting paths than you'd designed.

  6. Trust precedes investment - Users won't spend time learning a tool until they believe it's worth their time.

  7. Value perception is instant - Users decide if your product is worth it within seconds, not after completing a tutorial.

The biggest learning? Stop designing for perfect users and start designing for skeptical ones. Your users aren't eager students waiting to learn everything about your product. They're busy people looking for the fastest path to solve their problem.

How you can adapt this to your Business

My playbook, condensed for your use case.

For your SaaS / Startup

For SaaS products, focus on these implementation priorities:

  • Create pre-populated demo environments that showcase realistic use cases

  • Design 30-second wins that demonstrate core value immediately

  • Use progressive revelation rather than comprehensive tutorials

  • Delay complex setup until after users experience value

For your Ecommerce store

For ecommerce platforms, adapt these principles by:

  • Showing example stores rather than empty admin panels

  • Enabling quick product uploads with smart defaults

  • Demonstrating storefront previews before requiring design work

  • Focusing on first sale potential rather than comprehensive setup

Get more playbooks like this one in my weekly newsletter