Sales & Conversion

Why I Stopped Using "Best Practices" for Product Descriptions (And Doubled Conversions)


Personas

Ecommerce

Time to ROI

Short-term (< 3 months)

Last year, I was staring at a 3,000+ product Shopify store with a conversion rate that was bleeding out. The client came to me frustrated—they had decent traffic, solid products, but customers were browsing without buying. Sound familiar?

After diving into their data, I discovered something that challenged everything I thought I knew about product descriptions. The "best practices" everyone preaches—benefits over features, emotional triggers, urgency tactics—weren't moving the needle. In fact, they were making things worse.

What I found instead was counterintuitive: the most effective product descriptions weren't descriptions at all. They were solutions to problems customers didn't even know they were searching for.

Through months of testing with this client and several others, I developed a completely different approach to product copy that consistently outperformed traditional methods. Here's what you'll learn from my real-world experiments:

  • Why traditional "benefit-focused" descriptions actually hurt conversions

  • The AI-powered workflow I built to generate 20,000+ product descriptions at scale

  • How I used customer search data to rewrite copy that converted 2x better

  • The simple H1 hack that became our biggest SEO win across thousands of products

  • When to break every copywriting rule (and when to follow them)

This isn't another generic guide about features vs benefits. This is what actually works when you're managing thousands of products and need systems that scale. Let me show you the ecommerce strategies that transformed our approach to product copy forever.

Industry Reality

What everyone teaches about product descriptions

Walk into any ecommerce course or marketing blog, and you'll hear the same tired advice about product descriptions. It's become gospel in our industry, repeated so often that nobody questions whether it actually works.

The Standard Playbook Everyone Follows:

  1. Features tell, benefits sell - Always lead with emotional benefits rather than technical specifications

  2. Create urgency - Use scarcity tactics and time-sensitive language to push immediate action

  3. Target emotions - Focus on how the product makes customers feel rather than what it does

  4. Use social proof - Pepper in testimonials and reviews throughout the description

  5. Write for scanning - Bullet points, short paragraphs, bold text for easy reading

This advice exists because it works... sometimes. In specific contexts, with certain products, for particular audiences. The problem? Most businesses treat these as universal laws rather than contextual guidelines.

Here's what the gurus don't tell you: when you have hundreds or thousands of products, following these "best practices" creates a bigger problem. Every description starts sounding the same. Your copy becomes generic. Customers can't distinguish between products because everything is written with the same emotional triggers and benefit-focused language.

Even worse, this approach completely ignores how people actually shop online in 2025. They're not reading your carefully crafted emotional copy—they're scanning, comparing, and making decisions based on factors that traditional copywriting doesn't address.

The conventional wisdom also assumes you have unlimited time and budget to craft perfect descriptions for each product. In reality, most businesses need scalable solutions that work across diverse product catalogs without requiring a copywriter for every SKU.

That's where my approach differs completely. Instead of following copywriting best practices, I started following customer behavior patterns. And the results spoke for themselves.

Who am I

Consider me as your business complice.

7 years of freelance experience working with SaaS and Ecommerce brands.

The breakthrough came when I was working with a Shopify client who had over 1,000 products in their catalog. They'd hired copywriters to rewrite descriptions using all the "proven" techniques—emotional benefits, urgency language, social proof integration. The descriptions were beautifully written and followed every copywriting rule in the book.

The problem? Conversion rates actually went down.

After analyzing user behavior data, I discovered something that changed my entire approach to product copy. Customers weren't abandoning because the descriptions were bad—they were leaving because they couldn't find the specific information they needed to make a decision.

The client sold home organization products, and I noticed a pattern in their search data. People weren't searching for "life-changing organization solutions" or "transform your space." They were searching for incredibly specific things: "under-sink organizer for 24-inch cabinet," "spice rack that fits standard pantry shelves," "drawer dividers for kitchen utensils."

But our beautifully written descriptions were focused on emotional transformation rather than practical specifications. We were solving the wrong problem with our copy.

That's when I realized the fundamental flaw in traditional product description advice: it assumes people buy based on emotion when they're actually buying based on fit.

I started an experiment. Instead of leading with emotional benefits, I restructured descriptions to answer the practical questions customers were actually asking. I used their own search terms as the foundation for the copy structure.

The results were immediate. Bounce rates decreased, time on product pages increased, and most importantly, conversions started climbing. But the real breakthrough came when I figured out how to systematize this approach across their entire catalog.

This experience taught me that the best product descriptions aren't about persuasion—they're about information architecture. It's not about convincing someone to buy; it's about giving them confidence that what you're selling is exactly what they need.

My experiments

Here's my playbook

What I ended up doing and the results.

After seeing those initial results, I developed a systematic approach that could work across thousands of products without requiring individual copywriter attention for each one. Here's the exact framework I built:

Step 1: Search Data Mining

I started by analyzing what customers were actually searching for, both on the site and in Google. Using tools like Google Search Console and the site's internal search data, I identified the specific language customers used when looking for products.

For the organization client, this revealed that customers searched with incredibly specific dimensional requirements, compatibility concerns, and use-case scenarios. They weren't looking for "organization solutions"—they were looking for "corner shelf unit for small bathroom" or "stackable bins for craft supplies."

Step 2: The AI-Powered Content System

Once I had the search patterns, I built an AI workflow to generate descriptions at scale. But this wasn't generic AI content—it was trained on the specific language patterns and information hierarchy that customers actually needed.

I created prompts that prioritized practical information first: dimensions, compatibility, specific use cases, and technical specifications. The emotional benefits came later, if at all.

The system could process thousands of products and generate descriptions that felt personalized to each item while maintaining consistency across the catalog.

Step 3: The H1 SEO Hack

Here's where I made a change that became our biggest SEO win. Instead of using generic product names as H1 tags, I modified the structure to include our main store keywords before each product name.

So instead of "Bamboo Drawer Organizer," the H1 became "Kitchen Storage Solutions: Bamboo Drawer Organizer." This single change, deployed across all 1,000+ products, dramatically improved our organic visibility for category-level searches.

Step 4: Information Hierarchy Revolution

I completely restructured how information was presented. Instead of the traditional "benefits first" approach, I used this hierarchy:

  1. Compatibility & Fit - Exact dimensions, compatibility requirements, what it works with

  2. Specific Use Cases - Real scenarios where this product solves problems

  3. Technical Specifications - Materials, construction, weight limits

  4. Benefits & Outcomes - What you achieve by using it

This wasn't just theory—I tested this structure against the original emotional-first descriptions and consistently saw better performance.

Step 5: Scalable Implementation

The beauty of this system was its scalability. Once the AI workflow was set up, we could generate optimized descriptions for new products in minutes rather than hours. The system understood the information hierarchy and could adapt to different product categories while maintaining the customer-focused approach.

This approach worked because it aligned with how people actually shop online: they want to know if something will work for their specific situation before they care about how it will make them feel.

Key Insight

People buy based on fit, not feelings. Lead with practical information.

AI Workflow

Built custom prompts trained on customer search language patterns and needs.

SEO Integration

Modified H1 structure across 1000+ products for category-level search visibility.

Information Architecture

Restructured content hierarchy: compatibility → use cases → specs → benefits.

The results from this systematic approach were significant and measurable. Within three months of implementing the new description framework, we saw substantial improvements across multiple metrics.

Conversion Rate Impact: The most important metric—conversion rate—improved consistently across product categories. Products with the new description structure converted approximately 2x better than those with traditional benefit-focused copy.

SEO Performance: The H1 modification became our biggest organic traffic driver. By adding category keywords before product names across all 1,000+ products, we dramatically improved visibility for broader search terms while maintaining product-specific rankings.

User Engagement Metrics: Time spent on product pages increased significantly. Bounce rates decreased as customers found the specific information they needed to make decisions. The new information hierarchy helped visitors quickly determine product fit.

Operational Efficiency: Perhaps most importantly, we solved the scalability problem. The AI workflow could generate optimized descriptions for new products in minutes, eliminating the bottleneck of manual copywriting for large catalogs.

Customer Feedback: Support tickets related to product confusion decreased. Customers were making more informed purchase decisions because the descriptions answered their practical questions upfront.

The approach proved that effective product descriptions aren't about following copywriting rules—they're about understanding customer intent and delivering information in the sequence people actually need it.

Learnings

What I've learned and the mistakes I've made.

Sharing so you don't make them.

This experience completely changed how I think about ecommerce copywriting. Here are the key lessons that apply beyond just product descriptions:

  1. Customer research beats copywriting theory - Search data and user behavior patterns tell you more about effective copy than any marketing course

  2. Information architecture is conversion optimization - How you structure information matters more than how beautifully you write it

  3. Scale requires systems, not talent - Manual copywriting doesn't work for large catalogs; you need repeatable frameworks

  4. AI works when trained on real data - Generic AI prompts create generic content; custom training on customer language creates relevant copy

  5. SEO and conversion can work together - The H1 modification proved that technical SEO improvements can also enhance user experience

  6. Test everything, assume nothing - Even "proven" copywriting principles can hurt conversions in specific contexts

  7. Practical beats emotional for most products - People need confidence in product fit before they can get excited about benefits

The biggest lesson? Stop following best practices blindly. Every business, product category, and customer base is different. What works for a luxury brand selling emotional transformation won't work for a practical products store where customers need specific solutions.

If I were starting over, I'd spend more time on customer research upfront and less time on traditional copywriting techniques. The data always tells a better story than assumptions.

How you can adapt this to your Business

My playbook, condensed for your use case.

For your SaaS / Startup

For SaaS products, focus on specific use cases and integration details rather than generic benefits. List exact compatibility requirements, implementation timelines, and technical specifications before discussing transformation outcomes.

For your Ecommerce store

For ecommerce stores, prioritize compatibility and fit information first. Include dimensions, materials, and specific use cases. Use customer search language in descriptions rather than marketing speak.

Get more playbooks like this one in my weekly newsletter