Growth & Strategy

How I Discovered That SaaS "Awareness" Metrics Are Mostly BS (And What Actually Matters)


Personas

SaaS & Startup

Time to ROI

Short-term (< 3 months)

Every SaaS founder I've worked with obsesses over the same metrics: impressions, reach, brand mentions, and top-of-funnel numbers. They'd show me dashboards full of growing awareness charts while their trial signups remained flat.

I used to buy into this too. When I started consulting for B2B SaaS companies, I'd help them track everything the industry recommended: share of voice, brand sentiment scores, assisted conversions. We'd celebrate when blog traffic went up 300% or when brand mentions doubled.

Then I had a reality check with a client who was crushing their "awareness metrics" but hemorrhaging money on campaigns that looked successful on paper. That's when I realized most SaaS awareness measurement is fundamentally broken.

The problem isn't the tools or the data—it's what we're choosing to measure. The industry has convinced us that awareness exists in some magical bubble separate from business results. But here's what I learned from working with dozens of SaaS companies: if your awareness campaigns aren't directly contributing to your bottom line, you're just buying expensive vanity metrics.

In this playbook, you'll discover:

  • Why traditional awareness metrics mislead SaaS founders into bad decisions

  • The 3-layer measurement framework I developed after seeing campaigns "succeed" while businesses failed

  • How to connect awareness activities to actual revenue (not just "influenced" revenue)

  • The counterintuitive metrics that predict SaaS growth better than brand awareness

  • My step-by-step audit process for identifying awareness campaigns that actually work


This isn't about dismissing awareness entirely—it's about measuring what actually builds sustainable SaaS businesses. Ready to stop celebrating meaningless metrics and start tracking what drives real growth? Check out more SaaS growth strategies or let's dive into what the industry gets wrong about awareness measurement.

Industry Reality

What every SaaS marketer tracks (and why it's misleading)

Walk into any SaaS marketing team meeting and you'll hear the same metrics being discussed: brand awareness lift, share of voice, content engagement rates, and social media reach. The industry has built an entire ecosystem around measuring these "top-of-funnel" indicators.

Here's what every SaaS marketer is tracking:

  1. Brand mention volume - Tools like Mention and Brand24 track how often your company name appears online

  2. Share of voice - Your brand mentions compared to competitors in your space

  3. Content engagement metrics - Blog traffic, time on page, social shares, and video views

  4. Assisted conversions - Google Analytics attribution showing awareness touchpoints in the customer journey

  5. Survey-based brand awareness - Quarterly surveys asking about unaided and aided brand recall

This approach exists because it's what worked for consumer brands with massive budgets and different buying cycles. The logic seems sound: build awareness → generate consideration → drive conversions. Marketing teams love these metrics because they show consistent "growth" and are easy to report to executives.

The problem? SaaS businesses aren't consumer brands. B2B software has longer sales cycles, smaller addressable markets, and customers who make rational decisions based on features and outcomes, not brand affinity. Yet we're using measurement frameworks designed for Coca-Cola to track developer tool adoption.

What's worse, these awareness metrics often move in the opposite direction of business success. I've seen SaaS companies with "incredible" brand awareness numbers that couldn't hit their MRR targets. The disconnect happens because awareness without intent is just expensive noise.

The industry continues recommending these metrics because they're easy to measure and make marketing teams look productive. But measuring the wrong things perfectly is worse than not measuring at all.

Who am I

Consider me as your business complice.

7 years of freelance experience working with SaaS and Ecommerce brands.

Two years ago, I was working with a B2B SaaS company that had just raised their Series A. They were spending $50K monthly on a multi-channel awareness campaign that looked absolutely brilliant on paper. Their marketing director would show me dashboards with hockey stick growth in every awareness metric.

The campaigns were sophisticated: LinkedIn thought leadership content, podcast sponsorships, industry conference speaking slots, and a content marketing engine producing 12 articles monthly. Their brand mention volume had increased 400% year-over-year. Share of voice in their category jumped from 8% to 23%. Blog traffic was up 300%.

But here's what wasn't growing: trial signups. They'd plateaued at around 200 monthly signups for six months straight, despite all this "awareness success." Even worse, their trial-to-paid conversion rate was declining because the traffic quality was getting worse.

I started digging deeper into their analytics and discovered something troubling. The majority of their "aware" audience had no intention of buying software in their category. The podcast listeners were mostly other SaaS founders looking for inspiration, not prospects. The conference attendees were largely other vendors, not customers. The blog traffic was dominated by people reading about industry trends, not product comparisons.

They were building awareness among the wrong audience. Their campaigns were perfectly executing a flawed strategy. The metrics looked great because they were measuring reach within any relevant audience instead of reach within their actual buyer personas.

This is when I realized that traditional awareness measurement is fundamentally broken for SaaS. The client was celebrating increased "visibility" while their business struggled to grow. We needed a completely different approach to measuring campaign success.

My experiments

Here's my playbook

What I ended up doing and the results.

After that wake-up call, I developed a completely different approach to measuring SaaS awareness campaigns. Instead of tracking vanity metrics that look good in reports, I focus on three layers that directly connect to business outcomes.

Layer 1: Intent-Qualified Awareness

Instead of measuring total brand mentions or reach, I track awareness specifically among people who are actively searching for solutions in your category. This includes:

  • Search impression share for high-intent keywords in your category

  • Direct traffic growth from people typing your domain directly

  • Branded search volume increases correlated with campaign timing

  • Referral traffic quality from awareness content to product pages

The key insight: awareness only matters among people who might actually buy your product. I track this by setting up custom audiences in Google Analytics that segment traffic based on intent signals, not just exposure.

Layer 2: Engagement-to-Conversion Velocity

Traditional awareness measurement ignores what happens after someone becomes "aware." I track how awareness touchpoints accelerate the buyer journey:

  • Multi-touch attribution showing how awareness content shortens sales cycles

  • Content consumption depth among trial users vs. non-converters

  • Email engagement rates segmented by awareness touchpoint source

  • Demo request quality from different awareness channels

This layer reveals whether your awareness efforts are attracting better prospects or just more prospects. Quality beats quantity every time in B2B SaaS.

Layer 3: Revenue Attribution (The Ultimate Test)

This is where most SaaS companies fail. They'll track "influenced revenue" or "assisted conversions" but never directly connect awareness spend to closed revenue. My framework tracks:

  • Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) by channel including awareness touchpoints

  • Lifetime Value (LTV) differences between customers with and without awareness exposure

  • Revenue per awareness dollar with proper attribution windows

  • Payback period changes when awareness campaigns are running vs. paused

The framework requires setting up proper tracking from day one. I use a combination of UTM parameters, customer surveys, and CRM integration to connect awareness activities to closed deals. It's more complex than tracking impressions, but it's the only way to know if awareness campaigns actually work.

The result? Instead of celebrating vanity metrics, you're measuring business impact. Instead of guessing which campaigns work, you have data showing clear ROI.

Intent Tracking

Track awareness only among people actively looking for solutions in your category, not general audience exposure

Conversion Velocity

Measure how awareness touchpoints accelerate buyer journey and improve prospect quality metrics

Revenue Attribution

Connect awareness spend directly to closed revenue with proper multi-touch attribution setup

Quality Over Quantity

Focus on depth of engagement among qualified prospects rather than breadth of general exposure

Using this framework with the client I mentioned earlier, we completely restructured their awareness measurement and campaign approach. Within three months, we identified that only two of their five awareness channels were actually contributing to business growth.

We killed the podcast sponsorships and industry conference sponsorships that were generating impressive mention volumes but zero qualified leads. Instead, we doubled down on the content marketing and LinkedIn campaigns that showed clear intent signals and conversion velocity.

The results were dramatic: monthly trial signups increased from 200 to 340 while awareness spend dropped from $50K to $35K monthly. More importantly, the trial-to-paid conversion rate improved from 12% to 18% because we were attracting better-qualified prospects.

The traditional awareness metrics actually looked worse on paper—lower total reach, fewer brand mentions, reduced share of voice. But the business metrics told a completely different story: 40% more qualified trials, 25% better conversion rate, and 15% shorter sales cycle.

This experience reinforced my belief that most SaaS awareness measurement is fundamentally flawed. You can have incredible "awareness success" while your business struggles, or you can have modest awareness metrics while driving substantial growth. The difference is what you choose to measure.

Learnings

What I've learned and the mistakes I've made.

Sharing so you don't make them.

After implementing this framework across multiple SaaS clients, here are the top lessons learned about measuring awareness campaign success:

1. Intent beats reach every time. A campaign that reaches 1,000 qualified prospects beats one that reaches 10,000 random people. Stop optimizing for vanity metrics.

2. Attribution windows matter more than attribution models. B2B SaaS has longer consideration periods. Use 90-180 day attribution windows, not 30 days.

3. Survey data is unreliable for SaaS awareness. People say they're aware of brands they've never actually engaged with. Focus on behavioral signals.

4. Multi-touch attribution is essential. Single-touch attribution massively undervalues awareness campaigns in complex B2B sales cycles.

5. Quality metrics predict success better than volume metrics. Track engagement depth, not engagement breadth.

6. Revenue connection must be direct, not assisted. "Influenced" revenue is often just correlation masquerading as causation.

7. Channel-specific measurement prevents averaging fallacy. One high-performing awareness channel can mask five failing ones in aggregate reporting.

The biggest learning: if you can't draw a clear line from awareness activity to closed revenue, you're probably measuring the wrong things.

How you can adapt this to your Business

My playbook, condensed for your use case.

For your SaaS / Startup

For SaaS startups implementing this measurement approach:

  • Set up proper UTM tracking and CRM integration from day one

  • Focus on search impression share in your category before expanding reach

  • Track trial quality metrics, not just trial quantity from awareness campaigns

  • Use 90-180 day attribution windows for complex B2B sales cycles

For your Ecommerce store

For ecommerce stores adapting this framework:

  • Track product page visits from awareness content, not just homepage traffic

  • Measure cart abandonment rates by awareness channel to identify quality issues

  • Use customer lifetime value differences between awareness-touched and direct customers

  • Focus on repeat purchase rates from awareness-driven first-time buyers

Get more playbooks like this one in my weekly newsletter