Sales & Conversion

How I Doubled Conversion Rates by Breaking Every Homepage "Best Practice"


Personas

Ecommerce

Time to ROI

Short-term (< 3 months)

When I took on a Shopify website revamp for a client drowning in their own success, every "best practices" guide told me to add more sections, more features, more everything. They had over 1000 products, decent traffic, but conversion rates that made my client want to pull their hair out.

The data told a brutal story: visitors were using the homepage as nothing more than a doorway. They'd land, immediately click to "All Products," then get lost in an endless scroll. The homepage had become irrelevant - a beautiful but useless front door to a maze.

While every agency was building complex, section-heavy homepages, I decided to do something that made my client uncomfortable: strip everything away and turn the homepage into the catalog itself.

Here's what you'll learn from this unconventional approach:

  • Why traditional ecommerce homepage structure fails for large catalogs

  • The specific minimal design elements that actually convert

  • How to implement product-first homepage design without losing brand identity

  • The psychological principles behind why less actually becomes more

  • When minimal design works (and when it doesn't)

This isn't about following trends - it's about challenging assumptions and finding what actually works for your specific situation. Let me show you how breaking the rules doubled our conversion rate.

Industry Reality

What every ecommerce ""expert"" preaches

Walk into any ecommerce design consultation, and you'll hear the same playbook repeated like gospel. The industry has created a template for "high-converting" ecommerce homepages that looks remarkably similar across every platform.

The conventional wisdom includes:

  • Hero banner with compelling value proposition

  • "Featured Products" section showcasing bestsellers

  • "Shop by Category" blocks for easy navigation

  • Social proof section with testimonials

  • Brand story or "About Us" preview

  • Newsletter signup with discount incentive

This approach exists because it works - for certain types of businesses. If you're selling 10-50 carefully curated products, this structure makes perfect sense. You can spotlight your bestsellers, tell your brand story, and guide customers through a considered purchase journey.

The problem? This framework completely breaks down when you're dealing with large, diverse catalogs. When you have 1000+ products, trying to "feature" a few becomes meaningless. When customers have varied needs, a single value proposition falls flat.

But here's the uncomfortable truth: most agencies keep applying the same template because it's what they know, what clients expect, and what "looks professional." Meanwhile, businesses with extensive catalogs suffer from homepages that work against their core strength - variety and choice.

The real issue isn't the design - it's the assumption that one approach fits all business models.

Who am I

Consider me as your business complice.

7 years of freelance experience working with SaaS and Ecommerce brands.

The challenge that landed on my desk seemed straightforward enough: a Shopify website revamp for a client with a massive product catalog. They had over 1000 products, solid traffic numbers, but conversion rates that were bleeding money.

When I dove into their analytics, the pattern was painfully clear. The homepage was getting plenty of traffic, but it wasn't doing anything. Visitors would land, spend maybe 10 seconds scanning the featured products section, then immediately navigate to the "All Products" page. From there, they'd get overwhelmed by endless scrolling and leave.

The client's existing homepage followed every best practice:

  • Beautiful hero banner explaining their value proposition

  • Carefully curated "Featured Products" carousel

  • "Shop by Category" grid showing their main collections

  • Customer testimonials and social proof

  • Brand story section

It looked professional, followed all the conversion optimization guides, and would have made any design agency proud. But here's what the data revealed: the homepage had become a speed bump, not a sales tool.

My client was frustrated because they'd invested in "conversion-optimized" design, but customers were essentially using their carefully crafted homepage as nothing more than a sophisticated "Skip Intro" button to reach the actual products.

The real insight came when I realized that with 1000+ products, the strength wasn't in curation - it was in variety and choice. But the traditional homepage structure was actively hiding that strength behind layers of marketing fluff that nobody wanted to read.

That's when I made the decision that almost got me fired: I proposed turning the homepage into the product catalog itself.

My experiments

Here's my playbook

What I ended up doing and the results.

Here's exactly what I did to transform their homepage from a conversion killer into a revenue driver. This wasn't about tweaking existing sections - it was about fundamentally reimagining what a homepage could be.

Step 1: Eliminated Traditional Homepage Sections

I removed everything that customers were skipping anyway:

  • Hero banner with marketing copy

  • "Featured Products" carousel

  • "Shop by Category" blocks

  • Brand story section

This felt like design heresy, but the data supported it. These sections had engagement rates below 5%.

Step 2: Built an AI-Powered Mega Menu

Instead of hiding navigation, I made it the star. I implemented an intelligent mega menu that automatically categorized all 1000+ products across 50+ categories using AI workflows. This solved the discoverability problem without forcing customers through marketing content they didn't want.

Step 3: Transformed Homepage into Product Gallery

This was the controversial part. I displayed 48 products directly on the homepage - no curation, no "featured" badges, just a clean grid of available products. The homepage became the catalog itself.

Step 4: Added Single Trust Element

Instead of multiple social proof sections, I added one testimonials section after the product grid. This provided credibility without interrupting the shopping flow.

Step 5: Optimized for Mobile-First Experience

With products as the focus, I ensured the mobile experience was lightning-fast. Each product card included just enough information for quick decisions: image, price, and one-click "Add to Cart."

The psychological principle behind this approach: when choice is your strength, lead with choice. Instead of trying to funnel customers through a predetermined path, I let them explore based on their actual needs.

Elimination Strategy

Removed hero banners, featured sections, and "Shop by Category" blocks that had <5% engagement rates. Sometimes the best design decision is what you don't include.

AI-Powered Navigation

Built intelligent mega menu with 50+ auto-categorized collections using AI workflows. Made product discovery the star instead of hiding it behind marketing layers.

Product-First Layout

Displayed 48 products directly on homepage in clean grid format. Turned the homepage into the catalog itself rather than a gateway to products.

Mobile Optimization

Prioritized mobile-first design with lightning-fast load times and one-click "Add to Cart" functionality for impulse purchases.

The results challenged everything I thought I knew about ecommerce homepage design. Within 30 days of launching the minimal, product-focused homepage, we saw dramatic improvements across key metrics.

Conversion Rate Impact:

The conversion rate doubled from the previous design. More importantly, the homepage reclaimed its position as the most-used page on the site, not just the most-viewed.

User Behavior Changes:

Instead of bouncing from homepage to "All Products," visitors started engaging directly with products on the homepage. Time to purchase decreased significantly because customers could start their shopping journey immediately.

Mobile Performance:

Mobile conversions improved even more dramatically than desktop, likely because the simplified interface worked better on smaller screens. The one-click "Add to Cart" functionality drove impulse purchases we hadn't seen before.

Unexpected Outcomes:

Customer service inquiries decreased because the mega menu made products easier to find. The client also reported that customers seemed more satisfied with their purchases, possibly because they could easily browse alternatives before deciding.

The most surprising result? The client's competitors started copying elements of the design, validating that we'd found something that worked beyond just their specific business.

Learnings

What I've learned and the mistakes I've made.

Sharing so you don't make them.

This experience taught me that "best practices" are often just "common practices" that haven't been questioned. Here are the key lessons that changed how I approach ecommerce design:

1. Match Design to Business Model

A fashion boutique with 20 curated pieces needs different homepage strategy than a marketplace with 1000+ products. Stop forcing every business into the same template.

2. Question Every Element's Purpose

Before adding any section, ask: "Does this help customers buy, or does it just look professional?" Hero banners often fall into the latter category.

3. Friction Isn't Always Bad

Sometimes adding friction (like showing all products upfront) actually reduces overall friction by eliminating unnecessary navigation steps.

4. Test Controversial Ideas

The most impactful changes often feel uncomfortable at first. If a client says "That's not how ecommerce sites work," it might be worth testing.

5. Mobile-First Isn't Just Responsive

Truly mobile-first design means rethinking interactions and content hierarchy, not just making desktop layouts smaller.

6. AI Can Enhance, Not Replace, Good UX

The AI-powered categorization worked because it solved a real user problem - product organization - not because AI is trendy.

7. When to Avoid This Approach

This works for large catalogs and impulse purchases. Don't use it for high-consideration purchases, luxury brands, or small curated collections.

How you can adapt this to your Business

My playbook, condensed for your use case.

For your SaaS / Startup

  • Focus on speed: SaaS trial pages should load instantly and get users to value fast

  • Minimize navigation: Reduce steps between landing and trial signup

  • Clear value prop: Use minimal design to highlight core benefit immediately

For your Ecommerce store

  • Audit your product mix: This approach works best with 200+ products and frequent purchases

  • Test on mobile first: Mobile traffic often converts better with simplified layouts

  • Implement smart navigation: Use AI or manual categorization to make discovery effortless

  • Track homepage engagement: Monitor if visitors actually use your current homepage sections

Get more playbooks like this one in my weekly newsletter